@Cellexya And who babysit them to enforce this? I understand it's just an idea, but it really isn't feasible.

I edited my post

@Cellexya It's not going to happen. As Dawn said, been there, done that, didn't work.

It was just an idea

@_Confederacy_ They come back on Alts.

They use VPNs

How do you know, if they get far enough then they could trade with people and thus inflating the economy.

No.

Then they will use those to continue hacking, they could change their name and look like a new player. Who until attracts attention is a new player in the eyes of players and staff.

You bring up a good point with the economy

Players could be prohibited from trading with players on the watchlist. This can be achieved by removing their teleportation abilities (They would not be able to teleport home, teleport to spawn, etc)

Even without the two strike policy VPNs will be used, so that changes nothing

Yo

Another idea could be to unban the alts of players who have stopped hacking on their new account

As far as the ecoonomy goes, their items are all destroyed usually before they get in circulation

If they hack again they get perma banned or even IP banned

Here is an example of an appeal that should NOT be accepted:
https://forum.craftymynes.com/4156-erenity-s-ban-appeal

@Cellexya You know what's not fair? Ruining the server economy by xraying. Regardless if sorry, they had an unfair advantage by hacking. So why again do we need to show them fairness?

Some people learn from their mistakes

Well consider an appeal saying "I'm sorry, unban me now" which obviously does not look sincere or like it took a lot of effort, compared to a decently sized appeal where it is obvious that the player put at least some effort into it. The latter one would pass while the first one would not.

After that, the two strike policy would take place