@Quartz_King i just want to point out i just think the pumpkin trade is broken not "the villagers" although i see your point i have to disagree. Removing this one trade may increase the emerald value slightly, but mojang made it so emerald are meant to be rarer than diamond. I guess it is not "broken" but is being abused and it also encourages AFK farming instead of gameplay and i know this because i did have a massive AFK pumpkin farm and i moved every 30 mins so i did not get kicked for being AFK. In my opinion all it can do is fix the emerald economy and you say it will "make the rich richer" when that is wrong. If you mean emeralds will be worth more you are correct but the prices of player made shops will increase too making no effect on the rich and if you are talking about villager trades using emerald then they are actually losing emerald count therefore making them poorer (if thats a word). I am trying to not argue, i just really want the trade to be removed and if i have to fight for it i will. That is my opinon and if you have any more points i would love to hear them :P (maybe im missing something?)------Also i know alot of people who have taken the time to create the farms will be butt hurt if it gets removed and i would too but in many cases they got there value back in profit and at least broke even.

It would drive the emerald worth up significantly, because the pumpkin trade is people's main source of income for emeralds, take that away and people don't have an efficient way to get emeralds. The prices of player made shops would have to adapt to this change, making prices drop by a land slide because many shops (including mine) want to appeal not only to the rich, but to the newer players as well. It would make the rich richer because the rich right now have a large amount of emeralds, and if prices dropped they could buy a metric ton of items without effecting their wallet too much.

@Quartz_King its broken XD

I only see 4 people that think so. Removing the Villagers is only going to anger people, and drive the worth of diamonds and emeralds sky high, essentially making the rich richer. The economy is at a healthy balance where people that are new can get rich, and the rich can provide services for the newer players to get resources. It's not broken, it just seems that way. Plus, if the worth of diamonds and etc went that high, it's cause sort of a reverse inflation and probably cause the economy to colapse for a while. I will state again; If it ain't broken, don't fix it.

If it ain't broken, don't fix it

@TheForgotten20 mix masher was relatively new when he came on. look at 2 chill

He was not exactly new.

@misterkickman Yeah, my faction mates can't get in, and I'm gonna have to try and get them all a set. We know ally eh work that just led up to this problem is frustrating, but only 16 of us have been able to be online, and even then we can't do shit due to lag. I know this isn't your fault but it was near unplayable

You DO realize that was sarcasm right? xD

@FishW Canada has one too actually. it was like a month ago.

Yay someone remembered <3

Your order is ready @misterkickman . I'll be on most of today

@Blackened_Dawn appeal denied

Apple denied.

@misterkickman Okay I will be on in about 6 hours

What is your in game name?

@Retrochewy Is @Proxeria @CraftyMyner 's sister?

Maybe, maybe not :P