If he has valid arguments to bring, a debate is welcome. Snarky comments aren't the way to go though, Dice.
Socialism as it is written is a very much a potent system (in many ways).
However, states in the past (and in present) that are/were socialist carried it out in their own manner and put their own tint on the ideology.
I'm not against any ideology, it's all about the people presenting it; any ideology can be made beneficial to a society and form a fully functional and happy country when executed correctly.

Then why did you post it on a public forum?

Yes, I agree with R4. Steps like this making the life cycle of the game much shorter is what killed the 1.8 economy. The game cycle should be as long as possible, so that not only the economy is preserved, but people see enjoyment through progression.

And from a pvp standpoint, the new 1.9 system makes it extremely tedious and drawn out to kill someone with anything p2+, due to the immense regen and also due to the fact that the sword cooldown is longer than the immunity period (0.5 vs 0.63) causing people to get hit much less often; not only that but people quite regularly miss with their charged hit, meaning that sometimes damage is only dealt every 1.26 seconds. Making p4 a common resource subtly through steps like this would reduce pvp to nothing.

@Reptilian_OS_X it wasnt an attempt though. it is actually property of the Emprise now

I don't think anyone from Red Army will actually join your faction.

When I first saw the thread debuting the "Red Army", I thought: "Just another chump making yet another worthless faction. There's no way someone so new could bring people under his control." Yet soviet day by day exceeded my expectations. I saw his dedication and cohesion bring several players together; until one day I saw the official roster (this was during my inactive period) and it involved a selection of relatively powerful players.

Your faction to me has been a case-in-point of hard work resulting in reward: those posts about making music, banners, logos, official roles and jobs espoused your diligent mentality and it paid off. And now I'm witnessing the opposite from another faction; an effortless attempt to create a community, founded on lies and rudeness. It will not last.
I think your final move of transferring the Red Army to the aforementioned faction was not to form relations or to help the recipients, rather it was to show that nobody would want to move to that faction even if their former leader told them to.
Thank you for being a great presence on the server,
Mabzino

Dude, no offense, but nobody even noticed the "house of wolves" in the shadow of Apathy.
Try again next year.

God apples shouldn't be added; people can already book home just from the regen of food.

Zen, even if only 1 slot were to be transferred, someone could bring ~600 diamonds over, or 64 god apples, which would just be ridiculous.
Moreover, for Crafty to sift through every single person's ender chest would simply take too much time.

lol

oops.