@SharpSerac The devs intended invisibility potions to make you invisible to other players, that's why it's called an invisibility potion. Since CraftyMynes is a vanilla server which is SURVIVAL, it's safe to assume that you are meant to be invisible to everyone.

Invisibility potions are useless as they are right now. If you have any sort of gear it doesn't make sense to use an invis pot to raid any structures. I'd rather have people use invis pots than log on me, you can still find people who are invis by looking at the particles left by them when they run on the ground, the potion particles, and the sounds they make.

You can hold tab and see who's in the arena anyways, so using an invisibility potion wouldn't make too much of a difference.
You can still sneak and watch people from afar.

The devs intended invisibility potions to make you invisible in certain circumstances which they do.
The devs also created a sandbox game so you could so what you want not be tied in the game the way they choose.
It is not safe to assume that, nor is actually relevant.

It makes perfect sense to raid a monument with invisibility pots, it's an easy way to raid an end game structure without good armour or bothering to kill every mob in the way. The whole idea of giving something a use doesn't entirely follow either, should be now give nitwit villagers a use?
If there's no legitimate reason then why should be modify it.

Somehow I doubt when fighting people are watching tab all that closely in a pvp fight.
The same applies to looking for particles.

That's fine you can trey sneak and watch afar and perhaps you should do that, it does not constitute an argument for changing that rule however does it?

I think we have reached the limit of where discussion will lead us with this, it's up to the players to say what they think now and finally for crafty to come to a decision.
We are not gonna convince each other and it will just make it harder for others to come to the right decision.

@R4iscool1 The devs intended invisibility potions to make you invisible in certain circumstances which they do.
The devs also created a sandbox game so you could so what you want not be tied in the game the way they choose.
It is not safe to assume that, nor is actually relevant.

It makes perfect sense to raid a monument with invisibility pots, it's an easy way to raid an end game structure without good armour or bothering to kill every mob in the way. The whole idea of giving something a use doesn't entirely follow either, should be now give nitwit villagers a use?
If there's no legitimate reason then why should be modify it.

Somehow I doubt when fighting people are watching tab all that closely in a pvp fight.
The same applies to looking for particles.

That's fine you can trey sneak and watch afar and perhaps you should do that, it does not constitute an argument for changing that rule however does it?

I think we have reached the limit of where discussion will lead us with this, it's up to the players to say what they think now and finally for crafty to come to a decision.

I honestly think you're going against me for the sake of going against me. You know that nitwits have no use in the actual game, but invis pots do. This thread isn't about giving them a use, it's about fixing them so that they have their original use. Also, if you're in the arena fighting someone, you're stuck in there because of the combat tag, so it doesn't make sense to use an invis pot to go in there to catch someone off guard anyways. I'd like to hear @CraftyMyner 's thoughts