Post a Reply
3697 views

Render distance?

  1. 7 years ago

    r4iscool1

    Show in context
    Edited 7 years ago by r4iscool1

    While such a thing would be theoretically possible I think, given Crafties panel tracks players it's a bad idea for a number of reasons I think.

    3 Hours is a long period, the server population can easily double or triple which combined with a large render distance could easily crash the server or make it unplayable. We would be compromising our up-time for possible but probably minimal play benefits.
    The render distance last time I checked is set to 5 anyway.

    Another thing to note is that mob spawning problems are often not to due to render distance issues although they certainly contribute but Mojangs shoddy implementation of mob caps and various other bugs contributing. Setting the render distance higher would not impact on spawning rates hugely.
    For example when you log on in GMT afternoons where there tends to be 20 or less players the spawn rates tend to be very very good.

    The VIP+ idea is pretty bad too since the times we have the most VIP's online is the busy periods where having a high render distance would impact on the performance dramatically, it could also potentially violate the EULA.

    It is a nice idea however it's just the current level of restarts and Mojang bugs make it untenable.

  2. CraftyMyner

    Show in context

    It's a good idea but I think the rate at which it could update (3 hours) is just too slow. The server could find itself in a situation where it has way too many players and too much of a render distance. Or it would find itself with no players and a tiny render distance.

    It would also cause confusion when players ask what the render distance is and they get possibly up to 8 different results in a day.

    Ram is not an issue (we are using less than 1/10th of our ram) and tps calculation is quite a spammy process that fills the logs. A fluxation of tps at the wrong time could cause it to select the wrong render distance and cripple the server.

  3. CraftyMyner

    Show in context

    @JKELLER4000 "It would also cause confusion when players ask what the render distance is and they get possibly up to 8 different results in a day."

    I am not familiar with command blocks . are they able to use variables? can you have the command that tells the render distance to be dynamic also?

    well ok the reason why i want the higher render distance is

    http://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Spawn#Despawning

    "A mob will immediately despawn if there is no player within 128 blocks of it. "

    so if we set chunk render distance to 128/16= 8 all mobs that are no longer active will despawn! and then we will not ever reach the mob cap!

    right now we have render distance of 6? (6*16)^2 or a total of 9260 sqaure meters.

    pi*128^2= 51445 square meters.

    therefor only 9/51 *100= 17% of mobs are elegiable for despawn so after ~5 rounds of mob spawning and despaneing no new mobs will spawn because we will have hit the mob cap :(

    (I used bad math because mobs do not despawn if they are withing 32 blocks of a person so the math comes out a bit worse than the math i have shown if we remove 2 chunks from render distance :( )

    http://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Spawn#Mob_cap

    I guess if it is possible to raise the mob cap. if we are not going to allow mobs to despawn. then raising the cap would allow for a high mob count and a more time equally number of mobs. instead of just the 15 mins after a restart?

    if we are not running into ram or internet problems or hard drive bottle necks. then having millions of mobs stored off map not moving will not cause any cpu usage as they are not moving nor loaded!

    Render distance is stored in the server.propeties and cannot be changed by command blocks.

    It would still be a confusing concept to have the server give a different answer for what the render distance is up to 8 times per day.

    While we are not running low on RAM, we are 99% of the time maxing out our CPU and recently I just hit 88% usage on our SSD (causing me to split apart the RAID to get more space).

    The biggest contributor to lag right after chunk generation is entities (especially the ones with AI and logic). I purposely set the render distance low to enforce the mob cap.

    It's either a low render distance and mob cap or a player limit of 20 players. You can't have both 50-60 players and a render distance of 8-10, it's just not possible with the current performance of Minecraft and our server. I would like to upgrade to the "7700k @ 5.0ghz, NVMe SSD" once they come out of beta, but for now, I'm not sure it would be a good idea to rais the render distance/mob cap.