Pumpkin pies would be good for the Thanksgiving theme. For spawn egg, even though it's on your list of no's, I would argue for the Husk. It doesn't have a villager version, it's just a zombie, and it gives hunger, cause Thanksgiving is about eating a lot and not being hungry, with all the food items we get, the husk hunger effect will let us eat more! (and it's not because I want one, i actually don't want a husk, i just think the hunger effect fits into getting to eat and eat theme of the holiday) If that's still a no, then I would suggest a rabbit or chicken, and if the chicken, rename it Leftover Turkey or just Turkey, cause you always have a lot of leftover turkey after Thanksgiving. Also, in the spirit of the name, I think there should be a stack of some item, maybe paper, that just says "Thank You" or something like that so VIP+ players can give them out to people as thanks for being such a great community, or give them to staff for everything they've done. But it would have to be an item that isn't worth anything as an item, or else players would just keep them and be greedy, and that's not what Thanksgiving is about. It should be about giving, so I think there should be something VIP+'s can give to others.